A Shift in the Sands: Why 2013 Debtors Were Easier to Collect From Than Today

In the wake of the 2008 housing market collapse, the credit landscape underwent significant tightening. Lenders, aiming to mitigate risk, implemented stringent underwriting standards, resulting in a cohort of credit card holders around 2013 who were notably fiscally responsible and dependable. However, recent trends indicate a shift towards more relaxed credit criteria, potentially ushering in a surge of higher-risk borrowers.

2013: A Period of Rigorous Scrutiny and Collection Efficiency

Following the 2008 financial crisis, lenders, wary of repeating past mistakes, enforced stricter credit evaluations. This meticulous assessment of factors such as credit scores, debt-to-income ratios, and employment histories ensured that only applicants with solid financial backgrounds secured credit. Consequently, creditors and banks in 2013 engaged with a more selective group of borrowers who exhibited a higher propensity to repay debts, enhancing collection success rates.

2024: The Implications of Relaxed Credit Standards

In contrast, the current credit environment has evolved with the emergence of fintech and a general easing of lending standards, creating a more complex landscape for debt collection. Key factors contributing to this shift include:

Fintech’s Influence: Modern fintech lenders often cater to individuals with lower credit scores, introducing a two-tiered system that emphasizes high-interest loans for subprime borrowers, thereby complicating collection efforts.
Incomplete Financial Data: The omission of negative information, such as medical debt and tax liens, from credit reports hampers a comprehensive assessment of a borrower’s financial health. Additionally, incorporating data like timely utility and cell phone, rent and other off reports payments could offer a more accurate picture of financial responsibility.

Concerning Trends in Borrower Behavior

The relaxation of credit standards aligns with several worrisome developments:

Escalating Credit Card Balances: U.S. credit card debt has reached unprecedented levels, with balances climbing from $660 billion in Q1 2013 to $1.17 trillion in Q3 2024. LendingTree
Increasing Delinquency Rates: The delinquency rate on credit card loans has risen from approximately 2.40% in Q1 2013 to 3.23% in Q3 2024, indicating a growing number of borrowers struggling to meet payment obligations. LendingTree
Elevated APRs: Average Annual Percentage Rates (APRs) on credit cards have surged, intensifying financial pressures on borrowers and complicating debt repayment. LendingTree
Prolonged Recovery Periods: The prevalence of borrowers defaulting after initial on-time payments has extended the timeframe for debt recovery, diminishing profitability for collection agencies.

Conclusion: The Necessity for Prudent Lending Practices

The current debt collection environment presents increased challenges due to relaxed credit standards. While fintech innovations offer new opportunities, maintaining responsible lending practices is essential. Balancing innovation with stringent credit evaluations is crucial for lenders and debt collection agencies, while borrowers should prioritize financial responsibility to navigate the evolving credit landscape effectively.

Book a Free 1-on-1 Consultation Call with me Today!